Employers may seek to update employment agreements during an existing employment relationship to update termination clauses or address changes in compensation or benefits. However, where a revised agreement introduces terms that are less favourable to an employee, such as a provision limiting termination entitlements, employers must ensure the agreement is supported by fresh consideration.
In Chowanetz v. Ivor Forest Products Ltd., 2026 BCSC 1760 [Chowanetz], the British Columbia Supreme Court (the “Court”) considered whether an employee’s revised employment agreement was enforceable where the employer provided a wage increase, an RRSP matching program and a bonus program around the time the agreement was signed. The Court found that none of these benefits constituted fresh consideration for the revised agreement and, as a result, the revised termination clause was unenforceable. Chowanetz highlights the importance of ensuring that new contractual benefits are genuinely provided in exchange for an employee agreeing to revised terms.
Background
The employee was hired as a Moulder Technician in 2021 after relocating from Alberta to British Columbia for the position. His original employment offer included an annual wage review clause requiring the employer to review his wages each year to ensure they remained competitive with the local market.
In November 2024, the employee signed a revised employment agreement containing a termination clause limiting his without cause termination entitlements to the minimums required under the Employment Standards Act, plus one additional week of base salary. The revised agreement also documented an increase in the employee’s hourly wage from $35 to $38.50.
The employee’s employment was terminated without cause in October 2025. He subsequently brought a wrongful dismissal claim, challenging the enforceability of the revised agreement by claiming it was not supported by consideration. The employer argued that the revised agreement was supported by fresh consideration, pointing to the wage increase, an RRSP matching program and a bonus program.
The Decision
The Court rejected the employer’s arguments that the wage increase, RRSP matching program and bonus program constituted fresh consideration and found that the termination clause in the revised employment agreement was unenforceable.
- The wage increase
The Court found that the wage increase did not constitute fresh consideration because the employee was already contractually entitled to annual wage reviews. The employer argued that it had not conducted wage reviews in 2021 – 2023, despite its contractual obligation to do so, claiming that the wage reviews were discretionary and the wage increase was sufficiently generous to constitute consideration.
The Court emphasized that the employer could not rely on its own failure to comply with the original agreement to argue that the wage increase constituted fresh consideration and subsequently concluded that the employer had failed to establish that the wage increase provided the employee with any benefit beyond his existing contractual entitlements.
- The RRSP matching and bonus programs
The Court also rejected the employer’s reliance on the RRSP matching and bonus programs as fresh consideration.
The employer had communicated its commitment to RRSP matching in a letter dated October 31, 2024, before the revised agreement was signed. The Court found that the commitment had already been made and was not provided in exchange for signing the new agreement. Similarly, a November 14, 2024 bonus letter offered a $1,500 performance bonus, subject to certain conditions. However, the letter did not indicate that the bonus was contingent on signing the revised agreement. Further, the bonus described in the revised agreement was discretionary, unlike the specific amount offered in the earlier letter. The Court also noted that the revised agreement contained an entire agreement clause and made no reference to either program.
Ultimately, the Court found that the employer had failed to establish that the employee received anything of value beyond his existing contractual entitlements and the revised employment agreement, including the updated termination clause, was unenforceable due to a lack of consideration. The Court awarded the employee six months’ pay in lieu of common law reasonable notice.
Key Takeaways
- Review existing contractual obligations: Employers should identify any existing obligations, including wage review clauses, bonus entitlements or benefit commitments, before introducing new employment agreements. A wage increase or benefit that simply fulfils an existing contractual obligation may not support the enforceability of a new agreement and/or termination clause. Employers should also ensure that the revised agreement clearly documents the new consideration and the terms being amended.
- Ensure consideration is provided after signing: When asking an existing employee to sign a revised employment agreement, employers should provide a new benefit that the employee would not otherwise receive under the existing agreement. To constitute consideration, the benefit should be clearly tied to the employee’s agreement to the revised terms and must not have been promised or provided to the employee before they sign the revised employment agreement.
This blog is provided as an information service and summary of workplace legal issues.
This information is not intended as legal advice.